Stacey Arthur was a model and actress who rose to fame as Playboy’s Playmate of the Month for January 1991. She was also Mrs. Ohio for the 1990 Mrs. America contest. However, her life took a dark turn when her husband was killed by a fan in a murder-suicide, and she later sued Playboy for allegedly being raped by its employees. She died in 2019 at the age of 50 after a short battle with an undisclosed illness.
Contents
A Promising Career Cut Short by a Fan’s Obsession
Stacey Arthur was born as Stacy Leigh Darland in Naperville, Illinois on June 4, 1968. She started playing basketball at the age of 16 and was discovered by an American coach who offered her a scholarship to a junior college in Oklahoma. She then transferred to Iowa, where she became an All-Big Ten selection in 1997. She also played for the Jamaican national team and coached youth programs in her home country.
She married James Alan Arthur, a businessman and former basketball player, in 1989. They had three children from prior marriages. Stacey Arthur entered the Mrs. Ohio contest in 1990 and won the title. She then posed for Playboy and became the Playmate of the Month for January 1991. She appeared on the cover of the magazine, wearing a pageant-style banner that said “Miss January 1991”. She continued working for Playboy, appearing in numerous Playboy videos.
However, her fame attracted the attention of a fan named James Lindberg, who became obsessed with her. He stalked her and sent her threatening letters and phone calls. He also harassed her husband and children. On October 29, 1991, Lindberg shot and killed James Arthur on a street in Bellefontaine, Ohio, where the family lived, and then killed himself. The event was the subject of the second episode of the first season of The Playboy Murders titled “All That Glitters” that aired January 30, 2023.
A Lawsuit Against Playboy and a Life of Struggle
Stacey Arthur claimed that she was raped and sodomized by three Playboy employees at the Playboy Mansion on October 6, 1991, just weeks before her husband’s death. She said that two security guards and a butler drugged her, then raped and sodomized her. She filed a $70 million lawsuit against Playboy and others in 1992, alleging that the magazine’s inaction led to her husband’s death. She also accused Playboy of defamation, invasion of privacy, and breach of contract.
Playboy denied the allegations and severed its ties with Arthur after she appeared on two nationally televised shows where she publicly declared her rape at the Playboy Mansion. A deputy district attorney opined that there were too many inconsistencies in Arthur’s statements while there were no inconsistencies in statements given by the three employees who claimed the sex was consensual. The employees who had engaged in sex with Arthur were fired because they violated company policy by having sex during working hours.
The outcome of the lawsuit is unknown, but it is likely that it was settled out of court or dismissed. Arthur’s life after the lawsuit was marked by hardship and tragedy. She suffered from depression, anxiety, post-traumatic stress disorder, and substance abuse. She also faced financial difficulties and legal troubles. She moved to Florida and worked as an assistant coach at Radford and George Mason universities
A Mysterious Illness and a Quiet Death
Stacey Arthur died on April 5, 2019, at the age of 50, after a short battle with illness. The cause of her death was not disclosed, but some sources suggest that it was related to endometriosis, a condition in which the tissue that normally lines the uterus grows outside of it. She was buried in Bellefontaine Cemetery, next to her husband.
Her death was mourned by her family, friends, and fans. She was remembered as a beautiful, talented, and courageous woman who overcame many challenges and inspired many people. She was also praised for her achievements in basketball and modeling. She was the first Jamaican woman to play in the WNBA and the only one to win a championship. She was also a trailblazer, a champion, and a hurricane.
Stacey Arthur’s cause of death remains a mystery, but her life story is a testament to the highs and lows of fame and fortune. She was a victim of a fan’s obsession, a magazine’s negligence, and a society’s judgment. She was also a survivor, a fighter, and a legend. She left behind a legacy of excellence and empowerment in basketball and beyond. She will be remembered as a star who shone bright and burned out too soon.
